Skip to main content

Deflating a Bogey: Original SJCo districts were not drawn to stifle Native voting


Friends of Cedar Mesa provides visitors its version of what needs to happen in Bears Ears country at the renovated Silver Dollar Bar in Bluff, Utah. (Field Studio/University of Utah)

(Portions of this have been submitted for publication in the October edition of the Canyon Country Zephyr.)

By Bill Keshlear

On the road home from Monument Valley recently I stopped in at Friends of Cedar Mesa’s Bears Ears Education Center in Bluff, Utah, its home base.

It’s housed in a nondescript former bar renovated by the nonprofit on the main drag through town, between the upscale Desert Rose Resort, Recapture Lodge, a smattering of restaurants and gas stations, and a re-creation for tourists of historical Fort Bluff.

I wanted to find out what kind of information people get when they just walk in off the street. Does it align with information from other visitor’s centers in the area? Is the information presented as one viewpoint among many on how to preserve sacred archeological artifacts and unique geological formations? Or only Friends' point of view?

Friends’ mission is about protecting those sacred archeological artifacts from a variety of threats, including tens of thousands of visitors who have descended upon the area over the past couple of years thanks in part to publicity generated by nonprofits such as Friends in attempts to protect those sacred archeological artifacts. The hordes are expected to just keep coming. Fodor’s, the popular travel guide publisher, ranked Bears Ears at the top of its list of recommended places to visit in 2019.

The reincarnated Silver Dollar Bar is an effective brick-and-mortar platform for Friends’ environmental advocacy. Displays are museum-quality. Volunteers brim with the enthusiasm of true believers. It’s a labor of love.  

I came away from the brief stopover there with a clearer but depressing sense of how difficult it will be to bring together opposing sides in the hoo-ha over the monument.

I expected the docents to trot out standard pro-monument talking points about fears of imminent oil and gas development and other fictions. And the one I talked to did. Although there’s a remote possibility of drilling within the pre-Trump boundaries of Bears Ears, it’s mostly a Big Bogey driving outrage and donations.

In the wide-ranging conversation, the docent at Friends’ Education Center also said San Juan Mormons drew county districts to stifle Navajo representation in public offices
She was mistaken. It was another Big Bogey, this one routinely invoked to characterize county officials and residents.

I explained that the county drew the lines under the supervision of the federal government in the mid-1980s.


Gail Johnson was interviewed by KSL-TV in 2014. (KSL)

In an article published by Monte Wells in his Petroglyph, Gail Johnson, who was county clerk at the time, wrote:

"These historical facts are documented in county records and federal court records. Under the direction of the DOJ, the county did everything required to comply with the Voting Rights Act. There was no political or racial gerrymandering. If that were the case, then the DOJ and the federal judge were party to it." ...

"Again, documents show that the original San Juan County commission districts were created to comply with a federal court order. These districts were created to give more opportunity to American Indian residents for political participation in county government. These districts were created with the assistance and endorsement of the Navajo leadership.

"It is unfortunate that misinformation by some has lead to divisiveness IN this county and misperceptions of this county. Historically the average county resident, American Indian and non-American Indian, get along well with other county residents on a day-to-day person-to-person basis regardless of race or politics. There isn't perfection, but in general there is respect. There is cooperation. There is personal service. There are friendships. There are shared grandchildren. And, there are good people."


Johnson also mentions more recent events:

In the October 24, 2011 commission meeting, Commissioners Phil Lyman and Kenneth Maryboy agreed to form a redistricting committee to look at the 2010 census data to recommend any changes to the commission districts. Commissioner Bruce Adams was not present. That committee reported on November 14, 2011. Two rural areas east of Monticello (Cedar Point and Ucolo) were moved from District 1 to District 2 to put populations back into balance. Thus not disrupting a lot of residents and preserving community interests as had been done previously. Commissioner Kenneth Maryboy opposed this action preferring a complete redistricting of the county using census blocks rather than voting precincts.

The Navajo Nation filed suit against San Juan County two months later in January 2012 alleging that the county commission districts were unconstitutional.
 

An account of the federal government’s control over San Juan County beginning in 1984 also was written by University of Utah professor Dan McCool, who was hired by the Navajo Nation at $300 per hour to bolster its landmark voting rights case. It's a withering attack on San Juan County but consistent with Johnson's account of events 34 years ago. It begins on page 162.

The docent at Friends' Education Center said she'd never heard any of this.

She also said President Trump’s decision to reduce the size of Bears Ears was “illegal.” I told her Trump had broken no law. Other presidents had shrunk monuments. “Well, not as much,” she said. Among pro-President Obama monument activists, there’s a certainty regarding the outcome of federal litigation to overturn Trump’s proclamation. But it could go either way. The liberal-learning Brookings Institution suggests Trump has the power to do what he did. The outcome of next year's presidential election could be decisive.

Shouldn’t Friends be expected to cherry-pick here and there to promote its political agenda? Shouldn't  information from its "education center" be taken with a grain of salt? After all it’s an activist group at the forefront of a hot-button and expensive national environmental campaign.

(Friends' Executive Director Josh Ewing responds to questions about information the organization offers visitors to the Education Center in a longer version of this submitted for publication in the October edition of the Canyon  Country Zephyr.)

The organization's tactics include threats of drawn-out litigation.

Here are Ewing's comments regarding the Bureau of Land Management's oil and gas sale held earlier this month:

“We don’t think that’s appropriate for America’s most dense archaeological area to be completely leased with no planning and no tribal input and at odds with all the data we have from that area. We will do whatever we can to get the government to reconsider its bad decision, including litigation as necessary.”

Ewing seemed to be talking about a vast area west of Canyons of the Ancients, north of Hovenweep, and east of Bears Ears national monuments that was OK'd for oil and gas development in the BLM Monticello Field Office's 2008 Resource Management Plan – the document that determines what will open up for leasing and under what conditions. The 2015 plan updated under Obama's administration of BLM, however, raised concerns: "The RMP does not fully protect significant cultural and paleontological resources through special designations. ... Nomination of the most significant sites to the National Register of Historic Places and additional road inventories in the field office would help remedy these shortfalls."

Tribal input – required by the American Indian Freedom of Religion Act and the National Historical Preservation Act – was sought from several dozen tribes and tribal coalitions. (See EA, pages 46-49).




On November 5, 2018, the BLM sent invitations to participate in government-to-government consultations to: The Confederated Tribes of the Goshute, The Northwest Band of the Shoshone Nation, The Hopi Tribe, Kaibab Band of Paiute Indians, Navajo Nation, Navajo Nation – Oljato Chapter, Navajo Nation – Red Mesa Chapter, Navajo Utah Commission, Ohkay Owingeh, Paiute Indian Tribe of Utah, All Pueblo Council of Governors, Pueblo of Acoma, Pueblo of Cochiti, Pueblo of Isleta, Pueblo of Jemez, Pueblo of Kewa, Pueblo of Laguna, Pueblo of Nambe, Pueblo of Picuris, Pueblo of Pojoaque, Pueblo of San Felipe, Pueblo of San Ildefonso, Pueblo of Sandia, Pueblo of Santa Ana, Pueblo of Santa Clara, Pueblo of Taos, Pueblo of Tesuque, Pueblo of Zia, Pueblo of Zuni, Skull Valley Band of Goshutes, Southern Ute Tribe, Uintah and Ouray Ute Tribe, Ute Mountain Ute Tribe, White Mesa Ute (See Scribd document above, page 46).

The Pueblo of Acoma directed Chestnut Law Offices, out of Albuquerque, New Mexico, to respond to the proposed sale. The lawyers demanded the agency defer it. Their rationale was 3,000 words, more or less.

Apparently, the Pueblo's lawyers weren't too familiar with the protest process.

Here's BLM's response:

"These are comments on the NHPA (National Historical Preservation Act) process which has a separate comment period. ... There are no comments specific to the EA to respond to." (EA, page 130)


Ouch!

Popular post

ACTIVISTS LOSE BIDS FOR RE-ELECTION | Analysis by Bill Keshlear

 (Updated Dec. 7) The Nov. 8 election closes a chapter in the four-year saga of Bears Ears activists Willie Grayeyes and Kenneth Maryboy as the first Native Americans in Utah to govern as a majority on a county commission. Kenneth Maryboy and Willie Grayeyes (Bill Keshlear) The two Democrats lost bids to keep their San Juan County (Utah) Commission seats –  tenures enabled in large part by a federal judge who in 2017 declared that the districts in San Juan County disenfranchised Native American voters and ordered them redrawn. The new lines were drawn to ensure Navajo majorities on the commission - or at least a fair chance at electing majorities. In addition, Maryboy and Grayeyes got a boost from  the powerful Navajo Nation Human Rights Council. And Salt Lake City-based Democrats poured in thousands of dollars, even creating and funding a nonprofit called Rural Utah Project, or RUP. It successfully ran what, in effect, was the candidates' 2018 campaign and was successful. It mo

SUBMITTED FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION: A BEARS EARS MANAGEMENT PLAN | Background and analysis by Bill Keshlear

Roughly two and a half years after President Biden resurrected and even expanded President Obama's original Bears Ears National Monument, the Bureau of Land Management and Forest Service unveiled on Friday (March 8) their joint Draft Resource Management Plan and Environmental Impact Stateme nt, Volume 1 , a blueprint that would guide the agencies' land-use decisions for the next 20 or so years. Volume 2 lists citations, a glossary and appendices.         Bears Ears buttes on Cedar Mesa dominate the horizon of southeastern Utah and northeastern Arizona. They are visible from much of the northern part of the Navajo Nation, a spiritual beacon for Indigenous peoples for hundreds of years. Creation of Bears Ears National Monument was intended to protect archaeological, paleontological and geological objects. (BLM photos)   ( This was updated April 22, 2024, to include additional information and clarifications of earlier versions. ) The draft plan is an important benchmark ; Presi

INCENDIARY PROVOCATIONS CLOSE THE DOOR TO COLLABORATION | By Bill Keshlear

Jon Jarvis was director of the National Park Service during President Obama's tenure. ( Some of this has appeared in the Canyon Country Zephyr .) ( UPDATE September 1: On the road back from Monument Valley I stopped in at Friends of Cedar Mesa's Bears Ears Education Center in Bluff, home base of the nonprofit. Its mission, at least overtly,  is to tell people looting and vandalism of archeological artifacts is a bad thing. But I came away with a clearer sense of how difficult it will be to bring together opposing sides in the monument hoo-haw. I asked one of the volunteers there why the facility was not closer to places people have to drive through to get to Bears Ears country – like Monticello or Blanding. It’s about 100 miles out of the way en route from the north to a popular rock climbing site within the monument, Indian Creek. She said the Mormons would just burn down the building if located in either town. Really? Bigotry  sometimes bubbles up in strange places

UNCOMMON GROUND REVISITED | Perspective by Bill Keshlear

First Obama, then Trump, now Biden’s chapter of the Bears Ears saga Part 1, A new day? Biden administration trumpets its commitment to re-framing policy initiatives surrounding the government's fraught relationship with Native Americans. Part 2, C’mon down:   Federal land management agencies have been unable to contain the damage that tourism and outdoor recreation has inflicted on once-pristine public land. What’s changed? Part 3, Co-management vs. cooperative management: The differences are substantial, but tend to be conflated in service of political agendas. Part 4, Toward true “co-management" in Montana: Pitfalls and possibilities (Blackfeet attempt to re-claim Badger-Two Medicine south of Glacier National Park and Salish-Kootenai purchase Kerr Dam on the Flathead River). Part 5, Tribal perspectives at the forefront: An acknowledgment of the Biden administration rooted in the fact that Bears Ears coalition tribes consider the area sacred. Part 6, Priorities: The BLM a

Dems vs Benally: Party purity over civic-mindedness

EXCERPT from "Despicable Behavior Revisited." Rebecca Benally is a Navajo deeply engaged in developing a more prosperous San Juan County, Utah, and preserving her heritage independent of powerful forces beyond the county that, in her opinion, would permanently damage that heritage. However, her civic-mindedness was not enough to muffle the mean-spirited rhetoric adopted in the months leading up to the June 2018 Democratic primary in San Juan County by some pro-Bears Ears National Monument activists — surrogates of Native American tribes. They were supported by San Juan County Democratic Party leadership, many Salt Lake City-based Democrats, and a well-funded coalition of environmentalists and tourist- and outdoor-recreation businesses from across the country. Benally, one of only a handful of female county commissioners in Utah, was systematically defamed in the run-up to the primary. She ran afoul of an insular, male-dominated county Democratic Part

A NEW FOCUS IN BEARS EARS COUNTRY | Analysis by Bill Keshlear

  A Navajo social worker and an immigrant from Argentina - inspired by President John F. Kennedy's vision of America – took the oath of office on Jan. 3 to formally become San Juan County commissioners, governing a little less than 15,000 residents of a vast and spectacular swath of desert snowscape, canyons and towering pinnacles that is southeastern Utah's Colorado Plateau. (Above: One focus of Greater Bears Ears Partnership (formerly Friends of Cedar Mesa), based in Bluff, Utah, is a field program "to reimagine cultural preservation as an opportunity to reconnect Indigenous communities to cultural sites within the Bears Ears region." (Greater Bears Ears Partnership) Both have been community leaders for much of their adult lives: Jamie Harvey through administration of the Aneth Chapter of the Navajo Nation and the Utah Navajo Health System; and Silvia Stubbs through her longtime work at Utah State University Blanding.  They are not single-agenda-driven